Arminfo.info



 Friday, April 22 2016 14:31

Степанян Դավիթ Stepanyan Ստեփանյան David Давид

Ashot Manucharyan: Russia has been lured into a trap in Karabakh

Ashot Manucharyan: Russia has been lured into a trap in Karabakh

What was the prime cause of the April war, in your opinion? Who initiated it and who contributed to the aggression against Karabakh people? 

 

Now we are observing two processes. The first one is a global process and the task is to maintain the current world order, which numerous forces want to destroy. The forces seek to destroy the material resources and depopulate entire regions. The second process stems from some countries' intention to play geopolitical games. Judging by the analysis of the West's statements and Russia's reaction to these statements, I can say that the United States and Russia have agreed on the South Caucasus issues in general and on Nagorno- Karabakh in particular.  Today it is Russia that will settle the problems in the region. I think it is another mahaha-mahoola for people. There is no confidence in the world. Russia and the US are the key players in today's global confrontation. I believe the information about the division of influence areas can mean only one thing - to prepare a cunning blow by involving the adversary in something capable of deteriorating its positions for a retaliatory blow. Against this background, the April war fully fits into the logic of the specified geopolitical developments. The war against Artsakh did not start on April 2. It broke out much earlier - on January 26, when PACE adopted the resolution on Sarsang, which overtly called Armenia an occupant.

 

The logic is clear. What it the bottom line?  

 

Due to the 'four-day war', Russia has received excellent opportunities to settle geopolitical tasks meeting its interests unless the forces competing with Russia for the influence on the South Caucasus pose any obstacles. But the obstacles are already being observed and more obstacles are yet to come.     

 

So, does it mean that the West keeps aloof and Russia is to resolve the Karabakh conflict?  

 

Yes, it does. Russia has been given an international carte blanche to resolve the Karabakh conflict. The OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs totally support Russia's line. But Russia has already come across some problems. The first of them is the anti-Russian sentiments in the Armenian society. The first publication of the decisions to be taken on Karabakh will prompt protests in both Armenia and Azerbaijan and may trigger absolutely new challenges. The global game around Russia is described as an explosion of Ukraine and Turkey under Russia, and now it is the turn of the South Caucasus to explode under Russia.

 

So, we are observing something like a giveaway, aren’t we?

 

Super-careful Ilham Aliyev was given certain guarantees, otherwise he would have resorted to no such shady undertaking. Aliyev has received the guarantees from the West in general and the United States in particular. First of all, Turkey was instigating Aliyev to do it, but Turkey had no significance to make Aliyev unleash the hostilities. Turkey only prepared the Azerbaijani armed forces for the April war, sent instructors and fighters, thereby doing for Baku everything it keeps doing for the ISIS. Certainly, Turkey would like to see more extensive hostilities in Karabakh, but Ankara plays only a puppet role in all these games. Erdogan is trying to become something bigger, but the West does not let him do that. It is the global actors that play. Aliyev received personal security guarantees in Washington and Moscow.

 

What about the role of the Armenian leadership and the Armenian army? 

 

The Armenian authorities have been performing only one function since the beginning of the 2000s - they have been robbing their own people. However, it has become unexpected that in the world's point of view also the Armenian authorities' functions are limited to robbery. The formula of Armenia's leadership is as follows "Let be rob and I will do everything you tell me". Such a formula satisfies everyone except the Armenian people. But the global players and the thieves are not concerned with such a small detail. As a result of Aliyev's April adventurism, the myth about the combat effectiveness of the army and the myth about the capacities of the authorities in Yerevan demolished. It has become clear that the army was also robbed the same way as the whole country. And the only strength of the army was the Armenian people, which in the truest sense of the word have replaced stolen body armors with the bodies of their soldiers. It was the behavior of the Armenian authorities that made the four-day war inevitable. In the conditions created by the Armenian authorities, the war was meant to start and become a quite advantageous instrument for the external players for solving their geopolitical tasks. 

 

Did the Armenian soldiers’ actions – even without body armors – change the geopolitical plans of the major actors?

 

Of course, they did. Had those plans come true, everything would be much worse and Armenia would find itself in a completely different geopolitical situation with quite a different level of external dictate. There are two realities following the war. The Armenian people repelled the aggression while the forces promoting western policy in Armenia received fertile ground for their activities. Russia should have realized long ago that in Armenia it also deals with the Armenian people. Maybe the people are not noticed behind the crowds of robbers and rascals but the people actually exist, they make their own conclusions and cannot be ignored. Until quite recently the Armenian people undoubtedly considered Russia as an ally. 90% of the elite sold themselves but the people did not follow the elite and they had their own opinion about Russia. Today this opinion has worsened dramatically and this was one of the goals of the global players. Armenian people should not have been shown that two-facedness is spread also among the top leadership in Russia. It was a huge mistake. I see that Russia tries to rectify this mistake but the situation remains complicated.

 

Did Moscow have any alternative to its actions during the April war? Or did the strict neutrality between the conflicting parties lack any alternative?

 

Prior to the April events, Russia made 9 wrong steps, after which it had no other alternative than taking the tenth step. Russia is not in such a catastrophic condition that it has to put to question its successful participation in the global game for the profit received from selling weapons to Azerbaijan.

 

What can Armenia and Artsakh expect from the actively announced intensification of the negotiations on Karabakh? 

 

The negotiations will be held amid big tension in both Armenia and Azerbaijan. Since 2008 in Armenia the power represented by Serzh Sargsyan has been on one side and the people have been on the other side, with the 'mafia special forces' being in between. If the need for any concessions arises, Serzh Sargsyan will have to explain the necessity of these concessions to Bako Sahakyan and to the Karabakh residents, and 'the special forces' will decide what Sargsyan should do. Serzh Sargsyan has made the people ignorant in order to rob them more easily. Now Sargsyan wants to see the people as an actor. This is what Levon Ter-Petrosyan called for, by the way. But the people will not play the game of retaining the mafia forces at power. However, the people will be used in the game. Ilham Aliyev will be playing a similar game in Azerbaijan. Probably, this may lead Azerbaijan to chaos. It is Russia that should look into all these nuances because it has been delicately made to do it. Russia will be unable to make sense of it and will therefore get stuck in it. So, maintenance of the status quo is a matter of goodwill for Moscow. Otherwise, Putin will be blown up in the geopolitical space he has long been begging for. In Karabakh, Russia has been caught in a trap and it will be very hard for Russia to get out of it.  

POST A COMMENT
Input digits     

News
Philip Kotler`s marketing method finds acceptance in Armenian  universitiesPhilip Kotler`s marketing method finds acceptance in Armenian  universities
Srbazan: it is very important that medical workers feel protected in  ArmeniaSrbazan: it is very important that medical workers feel protected in  Armenia
Ministers of Culture of Armenia,  Turkiye met in AshgabatMinisters of Culture of Armenia,  Turkiye met in Ashgabat
Cascade complex may soon get its final look:  French WILMOTTE &  ASSOCIES ARCHITECTES presents concept of projectCascade complex may soon get its final look:  French WILMOTTE &  ASSOCIES ARCHITECTES presents concept of project
MP: Residents of Kirants continue to express their disagreement with  transferring their native land for moneyMP: Residents of Kirants continue to express their disagreement with  transferring their native land for money
Armenia receives observer status in  ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary  AssemblyArmenia receives observer status in  ASEAN Inter-Parliamentary  Assembly
Armenia, Egypt discuss prospects for developing military-industrial  cooperation Armenia, Egypt discuss prospects for developing military-industrial  cooperation 
Rocket Line - now for 60 months: Idram and IDBankRocket Line - now for 60 months: Idram and IDBank
Tunyan on situation in Kirants: There are always satisfied and  dissatisfied peopleTunyan on situation in Kirants: There are always satisfied and  dissatisfied people
MP from ruling party:  issue of power change cannot even be subject  of discussionMP from ruling party:  issue of power change cannot even be subject  of discussion
Lukashenko, Aliyev visit occupied territories of ArtsakhLukashenko, Aliyev visit occupied territories of Artsakh
Luxembourg Chamber of Deputies condemns de-Armenization of Artsakh by  AzerbaijanLuxembourg Chamber of Deputies condemns de-Armenization of Artsakh by  Azerbaijan
Mirzoyan: With help of int`l community, Armenian Government has taken  necessary measures to meet short-term needs of refugees from ArtsakhMirzoyan: With help of int`l community, Armenian Government has taken  necessary measures to meet short-term needs of refugees from Artsakh
Vardanyan family calls on int`l community to demand for Ruben  Vardanyan`s and the 22 other Armenian prisoner unconditional releaseVardanyan family calls on int`l community to demand for Ruben  Vardanyan`s and the 22 other Armenian prisoner unconditional release
Yerevan highlights CEPA implementation Yerevan highlights CEPA implementation 
Opinion: Lukashenko`s statements in Baku clearly demonstrate results  of Armenian, Azerbaijani diplomacy work Opinion: Lukashenko`s statements in Baku clearly demonstrate results  of Armenian, Azerbaijani diplomacy work 
RA Security Council Sec gives manipulative answer question about to  Russian border guards` presence on Armenian-Iranian, Armenian-Turkish  border  RA Security Council Sec gives manipulative answer question about to  Russian border guards` presence on Armenian-Iranian, Armenian-Turkish  border  
Armenia, Jordan against any changes in status quo of Old City of  Jerusalem Armenia, Jordan against any changes in status quo of Old City of  Jerusalem 
Turkish president, Georgian premier support peace in South Caucasus Turkish president, Georgian premier support peace in South Caucasus 
UJA draws international attention to violence against journalists UJA draws international attention to violence against journalists 
Tavush for Motherland movement not sponsored from outside - expert Tavush for Motherland movement not sponsored from outside - expert 
Border delimitation process successful - Armen GrigoryanBorder delimitation process successful - Armen Grigoryan
Gnel Sanosyan`s press office: Attributing  mansion to minister and  looking for manifestations of corruption are futile attemptsGnel Sanosyan`s press office: Attributing  mansion to minister and  looking for manifestations of corruption are futile attempts
Idram Junior and Koreez signed a memorandum of cooperationIdram Junior and Koreez signed a memorandum of cooperation
During the 33rd EBRD Business Forum, Ardshinbank hosted a panel discussion on economic and trade sanctions.During the 33rd EBRD Business Forum, Ardshinbank hosted a panel discussion on economic and trade sanctions.
Bagrat Srbazan: There is no alternative to resignation of current  government in ArmeniaBagrat Srbazan: There is no alternative to resignation of current  government in Armenia
Five Human Rights Defenders Initiative reports on illegal police  actions against citizens detained during protests in YerevanFive Human Rights Defenders Initiative reports on illegal police  actions against citizens detained during protests in Yerevan
Residents of border village of Kirants closed road to Georgia,  protesting border delimitation commission`s decisionsResidents of border village of Kirants closed road to Georgia,  protesting border delimitation commission`s decisions
Armenian FM meets with CoE Sec Gen in StrasbourgArmenian FM meets with CoE Sec Gen in Strasbourg
Investigative Committee of Armenia opens criminal case on police  actions in KirantsInvestigative Committee of Armenia opens criminal case on police  actions in Kirants
Azerbaijani puppet court extends illegal arrest of Ruben Vardanyan  for another 5 monthsAzerbaijani puppet court extends illegal arrest of Ruben Vardanyan  for another 5 months
Kakha Kaladze: Can you imagine our foreign minister would give speech at opposition rally let`s say, in Yerevan? Kakha Kaladze: Can you imagine our foreign minister would give speech at opposition rally let`s say, in Yerevan? 
Garnik Danielyan: Garnik Danielyan: "In this transition period,  Bagrat Srbazan is the  most acceptable candidate for premier post for me"
Mher Grigoryan: Baku is inclined to continue border delimitation  process in same format and with same algorithmMher Grigoryan: Baku is inclined to continue border delimitation  process in same format and with same algorithm
Armenia joins Oviedo ConventionArmenia joins Oviedo Convention
Border passes where it passes: Pashinyan spoke about Yerevan`s  principles and possible problems during delimitationBorder passes where it passes: Pashinyan spoke about Yerevan`s  principles and possible problems during delimitation
EU pursuing its own interests in South Caucasus - expert EU pursuing its own interests in South Caucasus - expert 
Russian expert on cleaning within Turkish Ministry of Internal  AffairsRussian expert on cleaning within Turkish Ministry of Internal  Affairs
Tavush for Motherland movement resumes protests Tavush for Motherland movement resumes protests 
CSI president writes letter of solidarity to Archbishop Bagrat  GalstanyanCSI president writes letter of solidarity to Archbishop Bagrat  Galstanyan
Azerbaijan extends arrest of former Karabakh leadersAzerbaijan extends arrest of former Karabakh leaders
Armenian PM reacts to attempted murder of Slovak counterpart Armenian PM reacts to attempted murder of Slovak counterpart 
Armenia, Azerbaijan sign Protocol-description of the borderline  sections Armenia, Azerbaijan sign Protocol-description of the borderline  sections 
Police opens road for participants of Tavush for Peace movementPolice opens road for participants of Tavush for Peace movement
Armenian Police intention to extend cordon around opera house caused  Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan`s anger Armenian Police intention to extend cordon around opera house caused  Archbishop Bagrat Galstanyan`s anger 
This is dishonor to all of us -  archbishop about his compatriots  held in AzerbaijanThis is dishonor to all of us -  archbishop about his compatriots  held in Azerbaijan
Prime Minister of Armenia: Armenia-Azerbaijan borders delimitation  and demarcation process  should become one of the tools for Armenia  and Azerbaijan to learn to live peacefullyPrime Minister of Armenia: Armenia-Azerbaijan borders delimitation  and demarcation process  should become one of the tools for Armenia  and Azerbaijan to learn to live peacefully
Police chief: it was necessary to ensure safety of 2 thousand guests  who arrived at EBRD eventPolice chief: it was necessary to ensure safety of 2 thousand guests  who arrived at EBRD event
Bagrat Srbazan announces number of meetingsBagrat Srbazan announces number of meetings
Thousands of police officers were deployed near National Opera and  Ballet TheaterThousands of police officers were deployed near National Opera and  Ballet Theater
Poll: Over 50% of respondents do not see anyone as head of  transitional government in ArmeniaPoll: Over 50% of respondents do not see anyone as head of  transitional government in Armenia
FMO provided Ardshinbank with a guarantee for a credit portfolio of 20 million US dollarsFMO provided Ardshinbank with a guarantee for a credit portfolio of 20 million US dollars
Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assess  Poll: More than half of respondents in Armenia positively assess  "Tavush for Motherland" movement
RA MoD delegation participates in IDEB-2024 defense exhibition in  Bratislava RA MoD delegation participates in IDEB-2024 defense exhibition in  Bratislava 
Tavush for Motherland determined to hold protest in front of Opera  House Tavush for Motherland determined to hold protest in front of Opera  House 
Russia never offered Armenia complete withdrawal of frontier guards-  Maria Zakharova Russia never offered Armenia complete withdrawal of frontier guards-  Maria Zakharova 
Samvel Minasyan appointed commander of territorial defense forces Samvel Minasyan appointed commander of territorial defense forces 
The Power of One Dram Sums up the Two-Year Program with Teach for ArmeniaThe Power of One Dram Sums up the Two-Year Program with Teach for Armenia
Russian foreign ministry rep on warming of Armenian-Russian relations Russian foreign ministry rep on warming of Armenian-Russian relations 
Russian foreign ministry rep on USA, EU double standards in assessing  protests in Armenia, Georgia  Russian foreign ministry rep on USA, EU double standards in assessing  protests in Armenia, Georgia  
Read more



Commented