Aram Manukyan: Armenian authorities pushed the idea of independent and free Armenia to the sidelines

Coordination Center of Armenian Associations of Sweden demand Azerbaijan to repatriate Karen Petrosyan's body

Areximbank-Gazprombank Group provides nonchip Visa Gold and MasterCard Gold cards

Shavarsh Kocharyan: Murder of Karen Petrosyan has many similarities with the cruel murder of American journalist in Syria

Ivan Kuhta: Difference of our political orientation will not affect Ukrainian-Armenian relations

Armenian President: Armenian-Georgian relations are on all-time high level

Special offer for Orange Internet subscribers

Armenia's Defense Ministry Spokesperson denies Azerbaijan's reports on exchange of captives

Russian political expert is skeptical of Azeri-Turkish-Georgian plan to form a military alliance

Armenian Government to cut its passenger traffic subsidies to South Caucasus Railway

Armenia and Georgia to build a bridge of friendship between Bagratashen and Sadakhlo

Armenia to build a farm to breed Sevan trout

Georgia conducts active measures to eliminate consequences of landslide on Georgian Military Highway

The Prime Minister of Georgia was presented the 40-Year Old Armenian Brandy

Prime Minister of Georgia arrives in Yerevan

Natali Pharm Company to be licensed to import narcotic and psychotropic substances to Armenia

Sports and Concerts Facility after K. Demirchyan to be signed off to Defense Ministry of Armenia for debts

Azerbaijan breached ceasefire on the Line of Contact nearly 40 times over the last two days

Ruben Melkonyan: It is too early to speak about Ankara-Tbilisi-Baku axis

Aziz Tamoyan: 200 Yezidi families from Iraq will settle in Artsakh

Hovik Abrahamyan calls for taking his statements the right way

Beeline offers Let's Talk service to corporate customers

VTB Bank (Armenia) starts providing "diamond" lombard loans

Developing military cooperation among Georgia, Turkey and Azerbaijan is not dangerous for Armenia: Armenian Deputy DM

Armenian man who fired at Turkish Embassy emblem in Russia to wait for court verdict under arrest

Orange begins “Smartphonization of Armenia”: bring your old phone and get a new smartphone at half price

U.S. Ambassador to Armenia addresses parties to Karabakh conflict in Armenian

Economist: Vorotan Cascade of HPPs must remain under state management

NKR Defense Army Commander: Baku blackmailing OSCE Minsk Group

Investigation Committee: Karen Petrosyan might be abducted from Armenia's territory

Manvel Grigoryan: In case of war in Artsakh, the boys of oligarchs and statesmen will also be fighting

No single Iraqi Yazidi has so far applied to Armenia for refuge

VTB Bank (Armenia) prolongs working time at some of its branches

Beeline grants its customers 1,000 intra-network minutes or 1,000MW Internet traffic on their birthdays

Paruyr Hayrikian to embark on hunger strike on 8 September

Aziz Tamoyan: Yazidis are killed on the same scenario as Armenians in 1915

Hovik Abrahamyan: I cannot wave a magic wand to bring everyone out of the shadow

Nikol Pashinyan urges Parliament to provide privileges to residents of near border Armenian communities

Roman Pope to serve liturgy timed to Armenian Genocide centennial

Washington refuses to sell Cougar military vehicles to Baku


Ivan Kuhta: Difference of our political orientation will not affect Ukrainian-Armenian relations

Zardusht Alizadeh: Arriving in Sochi, Aliyev and Sargsyan once again demonstrated the world that Russia is still the demiurge in the Caucasus

Masis Mailyan: Unlike Azerbaijan, global centers of force are not interested in growing tensions in Nagorno-Karabakh conflict zone

Sergey Grinyayev:The West’s sanctions are extremely positive for the Eurasian Union project

Alexey Kolomiyets: West's sanction will hardly sober Putin and the Kremlin

Hrant Bagratyan: Sanctions will have tangible impact on Armenia

Georgi Kolarov: The second Nagorno-Karabakh war is inevitable

Artashes Shaboyan: Reduction in consumer demand has a negative effect on supermarkets

Tigran Davtyan: If you have a telephone with you, it means that you have a wallet with you too

Shmuel Meirom: Israel is willing to contribute of its experience in the field of economy, but it cannot force Israeli business to invest in Armenia

Marine Karapetyan: Ameriabank on large business: problems and solutions

Eduard Sharmazanov: The opposition camp has no leader to steer the people

Alexander Zinker: Readiness of the Kremlin to protect its “Big Russian world” is dangerous for Russia itself

Vahe Davtyan: lternative power engineering should be developed regardless of fluctuations in electric power tariffs

Alexander Krylov: Taking into consideration the experience of the EU, Russia has to refuse maximal extension of the Eurasian Economic Union

Rasim Musabekov: Not only global but also the regional geo-political balance is changing

Zardusht Alizade: Apart, Armenia and Azerbaijan will always remain non-democratic fascist states

Victor Nadein-Raevsky: Erdogan’s address on Armenian Genocide contains new statements that were previously inconceivable

ArmInfo’s Interview with Victor Nadein-Raevsky, research fellow at the Institute of the World Economy and International Relations, Russian Academy of Science

  • by David Stepanyan

  • Tuesday, April 29, 00:19

On the threshold of the 100th mourning anniversary of the Armenian Genocide in the Ottoman Empire, the process of international recognition of the Genocide seems to be losing momentum. Do you agree with such an assessment?


24 states of the world have officially recognized the Armenian Genocide at the level of Parliaments and Governments. Turkey seeks to join the EU, and the latter ranks the requirement of Ankara’s recognition of the Armenian Genocide among several dozens of conditions for Turkey’s EU membership. Actually, this requirement is not vividly reflected in the documents and is restricted to verbal statements of European officials. So, the issue of Armenian Genocide is always in the spare magazine of Europeans. In the United States the Armenian Genocide recognition issue has not gone further than the Senate Committee so far. Nevertheless, if the Senate adopts a relevant resolution, it will be of great significance to the whole process of the Genocide recognition. This is what Turks fear so much especially given President Obama’s rather harsh statements on April 24. The international community drew a line under the issue of the Armenian Genocide culprits long ago, but Turks did not. The fact of the Genocide was confirmed by the Ottoman leadership’s decrees and by Istanbul’s court martial of 1919. In those years the Young Turks annihilated not only Armenians, but also Greeks, Assyrians and to a smaller extent Jews who were comparatively fewer in Turkey. Turkey set up commissions to nationalize the “abandoned property” of the Armenians, Greeks and Jews whom the Turks exterminated or deported. And all the Turkish statements that only 300 thsd Armenians allegedly died in Turkey sound too awkward and absurd. Turkey itself does not officially recognize the fact of the Armenian Genocide yet.


What about the public? Does the Turkish Prime Minister’s recent address reflect the public sentiments? 


One can observe an idea of repentance in the Turkish society. Even the leadership has changed its stance. Prime Minister Erdogan and Foreign Minister Davutoglu speak of “mass atrocities” and even apologize for that. This is already a step forward. Some 20 years ago Turkey propagandized hatred against Armenians. Some scientists are already speaking of the crime of the Genocide openly though some Turks cannot utter that term yet. This process is going on in a rather complicated manner, because several generations were brought up on hatred against Armenians. Therefore, the changes in the public consciousness are a fact that has become possible after the Justice and Development Party (AKP) came to power. It is the AKP that started speaking of the rights of national minorities, first of all, Kurds. All we can do is hope that the national courage of Turkey will prevail and clear the way for future relations with Armenia. After all, this crime clears the way for similar crimes as long as the Genocide remains unrecognized. I am convinced that Turkey should recognize the Armenian Genocide, because it will determine its future role in the world. It appears that Erdogan’s recent address contains new statements that were previously inconceivable.


Is this issue used in Turkey’s domestic policy?


It is used partially. There is a serious aspect concerning the discrepancies between Recep Erdogan and Fethullah Gulen. Even Nursists turned their back on the latter following his statements on Turkey's stance on Israel, for instance, condemnation of the Freedom Flotilla campaign. It is noteworthy that Gulen avoids making any statements on the Genocide of Armenians. At least, he has never used the term Genocide.  Nevertheless, Gulen's supporters have faced a wave of criticism after the U.S. Senate Foreign Relations Committee passed a resolution condemning the Genocide of Armenians in Ottoman Turkey. In Turkey they began to slam Gulen and his supporters for contributing to the resolution along with the Armenian lobby in the Congress. It must be admitted that Gulen bears no relation to that. However, the Armenian factor was used in the domestic political fights in Turkey. Incidentally, in Turkey they began digging into Gulen's roots to find any Armenian traces there.  Earlier, they absurdly claimed that Gulen had Donme roots.


So, one should not expect any tangible progress in Turkey’s policy on recognition of the Armenian Genocide, even if the power is changed in the country…


One shouldn’t yet. Nevertheless, condemnation of the atrocities at the legislative level is not impossible. What scares Turkey most is the property restitution issue that will inevitable emerge if Ankara recognizes the fact of the Genocide of Armenians. It's no secret that the Armenians in Ottoman Turkey possessed huge property even for that period of time. Therefore, Turkey avoids the property claims by Armenians not to face huge financial problems.


By the way, Israel does not recognize the Armenian Genocide…


The position of official Israel, which does not recognize the Armenian Genocide, is not only unfair but also illogical and far from humanity. The key reason of Tel Aviv's such behavior is unwillingness to lose "monopoly" of the only nation that officially suffered from the genocide - Holocaust. Here the campaign that started in Turkey long ago also played its part. I mean the campaign during which some mass media and writers were trying to prove that those who organized the genocide - members of the "Unification and progress" party were the Jews who adopted Islam. Nevertheless, Israeli scientists recognize the Armenian Genocide. Taking into consideration the fact that the historical and political science is strong in Israel, it would be simply funny, if not profanation. I think that the Israeli residents are twisting round at the political level trying to restore relations with Turkey that does not recognize the Armenian Genocide. This is unworthy of the nation, which was hit by Holocaust. In a certain sense in the political bargain with Ankara the Western countries are trying to use the Armenian Genocide issue. In 1995 our State Duma adopted a statement calling this crime - the genocide.


The year 2015 will mark the 100th mourning anniversary of the Armenian Genocide. Do you think any progress will be registered in the process of its international recognition?


I am confident that more attention will be drawn at the Armenian Genocide recognition problem in the world in 2015. We may expect the relevant steps from many states that do not depend on the political relations with Turkey. However, only the key countries of the world, which think they are the masters of the world, may finally settle this issue, for instance, the USA, although the recent events have demonstrated that not all the countries are ready to be vulnerable to the USA. Today Russia does not have another choice. Meanwhile, the Armenian Genocide has horrible consequences. I mean Hitler's words and other genocide actions, for instance in Africa and Cambodia. Only the timely taken measures against display of Nazism may stop such brutalities. For instance, young men in Ukraine, whose fathers and grandfathers were fighting Nazism during the Great Patriotic War, were dinned into head that Stepan Bandera is their leader. As a result, these grass-green young men are in fact destroying Ukraine under the nazi slogans of the "Right sector". The Americans do not want to see that. It is just a real politic for them and nothing else.


The impact of Islamism, particularly, the impact of Turkey in Russia’s North Caucasus is one of the trump cards of Turkish diplomats in the talks with Moscow. What is the situation like today?  


At present, in its policy regarding Turkey Russia has been actively using the Muslim factor. In 2013, in Petersburg a big sector

of "Nurjullar" sect (250 people) and another one - 120 people were revealed. Both were headed by Turks, although Azerbaijanis and ethnic Central Asia residents, etc. were within the sect. All these people are being programmed not at harmless forms of Islamism. For this reason, the activity of this sect is forbidden in Russia and even the books by Said Nursi are also forbidden. As for the Caucasus, here there are many propagandists and various Muslim movements, first of all, Wahabi and Salafis, have been trying to infatuate the hearts of the young people. The authorities do not take enough measures to stop dissemination of such sects in Russia, although policemen have become rather active for the last period of time when suppressing terrorism. I’d say that traditional Islam is a serious obstacle on the way of dissemination of such radical movements. Big funds should be invested in the economy of North Caucasus to employ young people and hinder their joining radical sects. Islamist movements are being disseminated not only in the Caucasus but also in the Volga region, Bashkiria and Tatarstan, although the Turkish vocational schools were shut down here several years ago.


Would you specify the final goal?


The final goal of dissemination of the Islamist movements in Russia is creation of the new elite oriented not at the Russians and Russia but at Turkey. In Turkey they have already created such an elite, and we see what it has resulted in. The conflict between Gul and Erdogan is the conflict between the new elite brought up in the vocational schools and universities created by the Hizmet and the authorities.  All these missionaries have been striving to split Russia through capturing the hearts of young Muslims. They want to split the multi-national state, which would make it possible to separate Russian Muslims from the rest of the country. This is categorically inadmissible to us. Neighboring Azerbaijan has found itself in rather a difficult situation resulting from the Turkey-sponsored Muslim currents. Turkey's pressure has even forced Baku to fire Gulen's Hizmet movement-friendly minister. The movement is based on the Sunni Islam, while Shia Islam is a traditional religion in Azerbaijan. Groups of Wahabi and Salafis are also a major threat to the traditional Shia Islam. All this constitutes threat to the incumbent authorities and the public in Baku. That is why Azerbaijan tries by all means possible to avoid differentiating nationality and religion and to keep integrity. They have even created a range of myths to that end. One of the myths, for instance, says that Azerbaijanis are just about to be the most ancient nation in the world.  Scientifically, all this looks quite silly, indeed. All these efforts result from phobias and aspirations to create a nation from nothing. However, this young country that has borrowed from Iran even its name has no other way out.

Send to a friend

To (e-mail)

Your name



View comments (0)

Be first to comment on this article

* Indicates required fields