Azerbaijan mounts another sabotage attack on Line of Contact, Armenian side has 1 victim and 2 wounded

Helsinki Citizens' Assembly Vanadzor Office urges Armenian Defense Ministry to look into military conscription of a kyphotic young man

Armenia suffers no losses during crossfire initiated by Azerbaijan on Armenian-Azeri border

Tigran Davtyan: If you have a telephone with you, it means that you have a wallet with you too

Armenia's former prime minister: The indicator of the economic growth in Armenia is extremely low for the first half of 2014

RPA: OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs’ latest statement was addressed to Azerbaijan

French citizen lost in Gegarkunik region of Armenia

RPA does not hurry to assess 100 day activity of Hovik Abrahamyan's government

Serzh Sargsyan sees no need in arming of population of border villages

Seyran Ohanyan: Armenia has been putting in place ‘engineering facilities’ along with other measures to prevent attempts by Azerbaijani sabotage groups to infiltrate into its territory

Charges brought against Levon Hayrapetyan

Azeri State Committee for Refugees: Issues of the return of Dilgam Asgarov and Shahbaz Guliyev and the transfer of Hasan Hasanov's dead body are under control of President Aliyev

Armenian Government tries to repay its debts by transferring state-owned enterprises' assets to a U.S. company

Armenian environmentalists comment on Red Book apes imported to Armenia

All U.S. citizens traveling to or residing in Armenia are strongly encouraged to enroll in the Department of State's Smart Traveler Enrollment Program

The ICRC has already started talks to return Azeri saboteur's corpse, Azerbaijani State Committee says

Stepan Safaryan: OSCE Minsk Group prefers stroking naughty Azerbaijan

Edward Nalbandian advises his Azerbaijani counterpart not to use international arena for propaganda

Political expert: OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs want to lobby the meeting between Presidents of Armenia and Azerbaijan

Shmuel Meirom: Israel is willing to contribute of its experience in the field of economy, but it cannot force Israeli business to invest in Armenia

OSCE Minsk Group Co-Chairs express their serious concern about the increase in tensions and violence in Karabakh conflict zone

Heritage Party considers Volodya Avetisyan to be a political prisoner

Rostelecom expands its sales and customer service network

Arthur Grigoryan appointed commercial manager of mobile communication division at Beeline Armenia

Edward Nalbandian: Armenia wants to start a dialogue on abolishment of visa regime with EU

Edward Nalbandian: Unlike Azerbaijan, Armenia has been consistently proving its adherence to the principles of international law

No third tailing dump in Tukhmanuk

Edward Nalbandian: Turkey, which is striving to the EU, has shut down the border to the neighboring state, whereas a principle of free movement at the EU territory is one of the basic norms

Ali Hasanov: If international organizations can not resolve the conflict, let them step aside and the two neighboring states solve the problem themselves

Vladimir Dorokhin: None of the Azerbaijanis detained at the territory of Armenia are Russian citizens

"Mika cement" to replace owner

Deputy Prime Minister of Azerbaijan: The Azerbaijani people do not believe the OSCE Minsk Group

OSCE representative concerned about Armenia court decision forcing media outlets to disclose sources

The NKR Minister of Foreign Affairs received the Head of the ICRC Mission in Nagorno-Karabakh

Members of Karabakh parliament made a statement to protect Levon Hayrapetyan

"Vallex" Group celebrates Miner's Day

Commandos: Levon Hayrapetyan's arrest is a result of hard work of Azerbaijani and Russian secret services

Ivan Kukhta: The government of Ukraine owns irrefutable evidence of separatists' blame for the crash of the Malaysian Boeing

According to the results of the first half of 2014, growth rates of Ameriabank's indices exceed average market level

ACBA-CREDIT ACRICOLE BANK and American Express have announced the launch of new card "The ACBA-CREDIT AGRICOLE BANK American Express® Cash Back Card"

No visa regime between Georgia and Armenia

Vahagn Hovnanyan: It is necessary to hold a protest action in front Russia's Embassy in Armenia to support Levon Hayrapetyan

Political expert: Growth of tension at the border is a regular ill-fated expression of complexes by Azerbaijan

James Warlick: The number of incidents and resulting deaths and injuries is also a setback in our efforts to work with parties to find a lasting peace

Lake Sevan is on the verge of environmental disaster

Life of the three persons injured in Kashatagh as a result of a landmine explosion is out of danger

EU welcomes ruling of Turkish Constitutional Court regarding investigation into the 2007 murder of Turkish- Armenian journalist Hrant Dink

Armavir mayor's car explodes in mine-studded territory of Kashatagh

Newspaper: Armenian oligarch's company worked in the shadow

Nagorno-Karabakh Police publish details of the case of Azeri saboteurs


Georgian Parliament Speaker to Visit Israel

Jury to Pass Verdict on Accomplices to Georgian General's Murderer in Moscow

Municipal Transport Drivers to Hold Protest Rally Throughout Georgia

The National Press Day

Saakashvili's Party States it is Important to Conduct the Second Round of Elections till July 19

Historical Changes Have Occurred in Georgia - President

Israeli Minister of Agriculture is Paying Official Visit to Georgia

Power Restrictions Imposed in Tbilisi since June 23, 2014

Ramadan begins on June 29

Azerbaijan's democratic forces calling for the Association with the EU

Georgian MFA Responds to U.S. Embassy's Statement, Connected with Incidents during Election Campaign

Georgian Ambassador Demands Explanations from Turkish MFA

Georgian Citizens Abroad not to Participate in Local Elections

Georgian President Delegates Prime Minister to Sign Associated Agreement

Georgian Leadership Welcomes Presidential Elections in Ukraine

We do not Need Saakashvili's Type Mediators in our Relations with Ukraine - Lavrov

Caucasian Muslims Department (CMD) opens an office in Iran, next will be Saudi Arabia

Poroshenko States he Has not Offered Georgian Ex-President Mikheil Saakashvili Adviser's Post

Russia not to Punish Georgia for Signing Associated Agreement with EU-Kosachev

James Appathurai Writes about Georgia in his Page in Facebook

Blogger Abdul Abilov sentenced to five and a half years

Vugar Aliyev committed to strengthening the responsibility of Internet resources

Civil society urges Aliyev to defend democracy

Giorgi Tarkhan-Mouravi: Confrontation around the Crimea will speed up Ukraine's European integration

ArmInfo’s Interview with Giorgi Tarkhan-Mouravi, Director of the Tbilisi-based Institute for Policy Studies

  • by David Stepanyan

  • Thursday, March 13, 20:08

Can we say that the Kremlin is trying to repeat the South Ossetian scenario in the Crimea today? What are the prospects of that scenario? 


Moscow's methods in the Crimea and South Ossetia bear certain similarities. Among those methods are determination to change the formal-legal status of the region, complete lies and propaganda of the Russian Mass Media, secret deployment of troops and denial of the presence of Russian troops in the region amid negligence of the international law, application of double standards in the foreign policy, and issue of Russian passports as a tactical step. Similarities can always be found and they are always conditional and sometimes even delusive. At the same time, there are also certain tangible differences in Russia's goals and approaches, in the situation in Ukraine and the Crimea.  The actions of the Ukrainian authorities and the West's response are also different. Russia has strong nostalgic feelings connected with the Crimea. Therefore, Moscow mulls Crimea's unification with Russia, while South Ossetia was important for Russia as a military foothold and a lever of influence on Georgia. In addition, there is growing need to distract the Russian population's attention from the deteriorating situation in that country and Putin's inadequacy that is becoming more and more obvious as well as the negligence he displays towards Russia's long-term interests. 


Let’s put aside the twists and turns of the information war. What do you think is really going on around Ukraine?  


The clash of the two ideas for development of Ukraine is taking place: one - towards integration with the West and the other one - joining the Eurasian project and having "sovereign" democracy similar to the Russian democracy. On the other hand, the clash of geo-political and strategic interests of the West and Russia is obvious in Ukraine. However, I should specially emphasize that in the geo-political and strategic sense Ukraine is more important for Russia than for the western community. The clash between the "soft" force of the West and the "harsh" force of Russia is taking place in Ukraine. In the situation in Ukraine Moscow often ignores the international law when it comes out at the short end. 


Almost all the statements of western politicians and diplomats condemning Russia’s actions in Ukraine are actually inefficient, except US Secretary of State John Kerry’s assessments. What are the reasons of such passivity?


As usually, US political figures come out from more principal and strict positions. I do not mean only the assessments by US Secretary John Kerry. Barack Obama's assessments of the processes in Ukraine and the Crimea were also quite harsh. Relying on the existing sources of information, not all European politicians make 'unprincipled' statements and Ms. Merkel also gave quite tough assessment of Putin and his policy. The assessments cannot be effective unless there is a threat of efficient measures. In the given case, the USA and some other countries have already begun taking certain measures and the EU will probably impose some economic sanctions on Russia and freeze cooperation with that country in a range of fields. Analyzing the reasons of why some politicians, especially in Europe, are so cautious in their assessments, one should not forget about how fragile is the situation in Europe, and how important are the Russian energy resources and market for Europe. Much less important is the fear for reversal of the process rehabilitation of European economies. Meanwhile, even a threat of sanctions against Moscow has already led to a fall of the Russian ruble and shares. And this is not the end yet.


Given Moscow’s refusal to hold direct negotiations with the new Ukrainian authorities, Kyiv can play no role in the confrontation of the West and Russia. May this become a starting point of military escalation in the diplomatic war for Ukraine? Or do you think the geopolitical confrontation will result in new agreements and a new status quo?


Direct military confrontation in the conflict between the West and Russia is hardly possible. However, the West will show big military aid to Ukraine. All this will be accompanied by speeding up integration processes of Ukraine. The new status-quo in the world order may appear sooner or later. However, at present we live in a rather dynamic time. For this reason, one can say about a new status quo only relatively or within specific frames. As regards the possible consequences of the situation around Ukraine, I think Ukraine is likely to overcome the main existential challenges, but the problem of the Crimea's status will still remain. Russia and Putin, in particular, are not always predictable. So, it is hard to say for sure, how Moscow will act regarding Eastern Ukraine. 


Do you think that if Moscow gives up the project on restoration of its influence in the post-Soviet space, it will give an impetus to western and Turkish disintegration projects in Russia’s territory?


Despite Moscow's positions, I think that disintegration processes in Russia have already started. But are the Russian laws fully functioning in Chechnya or the Far East? All this has been taking place against the background of the worsening demographic situation in Russia, growth of ethnic nationalism and relative weakening of the country. The West is hardly striving to disintegrate Russia. As for Turkey, it is entering a rather hard time and it does not have enough resources for implementation of such a serious project. Disintegration processes are available in Russia itself and are stemming from the southeastern part of the country.


Ukraine assumed the CIS chairmanship in January 2014. How may the shift in power in Kyiv and the ambiguous situation in the Crimea affect the prospects of the chairmanship and the prospects of the CIS in general?    


This will depend on whether Russia will recognize the legitimacy of Kyiv’s authorities in particular and on development of the Ukrainian-Russian relations in general. Even if everything is all right formally, the CIS will continue existing as a talkfest rather than an efficient integration organization.

Send to a friend

To (e-mail)

Your name



View comments (0)

Be first to comment on this article

* Indicates required fields